Cinnamon Toast Shot

Tastes exactly like the last sip of milk after a bowl of cinnamon cereal — warm, sweet and dangerously easy. Fireball does the spice, RumChata does the cream.

Add a recipe photo
Advertisement

Substitutions

  • No RumChata? Use horchata plus a splash of spiced rum.
  • Swap Fireball for any cinnamon whisky.

Batch version

For 12 shots, combine 9 oz Fireball and 9 oz RumChata in a chilled pitcher; stir and pour.

FAQ

Does it curdle?

Serve it cold and drink it fresh. RumChata can separate slightly if it sits with high-proof cinnamon whisky for a long time.

Is it strong?

Medium. Two half-ounce pours of ~33% ABV spirits land it in the middle of the pack.

You might also like

At a glance
Base liquor
Whiskey
Flavor
Creamy · Spicy · Sweet
Strength
Medium
Difficulty
Easy
Prep time
2 min
Method
Build
Glassware
1.5 oz shot glass
Best for
Birthday, Game Day
Est. cost/shot
$1.75
Drink responsibly. For adults 21+. Never drink and drive.